Year: 2011 (Date of Decision: 12 December, 2011)
Forum, Country: Constitutional Court; Italy
Standards, Rights: Non-discrimination and equal protection of the law; Right to health; Right to education; Right to social security; Children; Persons with disabilities; Migrants
Summary Background: Juveniles of non-European Union origin with disabilities and without a long-term resident permit, which can be acquired only after five years of permanent residency, and their families were excluded from the benefits of financial assistance (indennità di frequenza). The allowance aims at helping disabled juveniles and their families who face economic difficulties in covering the medical needs, as well as other special needs they may have, in the area of education and vocational training to promote their integration in society. The Genoa Court of Appeal referred the case to the Constitutional Court for the review of the constitutionality of this discrimination in the assignment of this social benefit (article 80.19 of Law no. 388 of 23 December 2000).
Holding: Pursuant to article 117.1 of the Constitution, which requires legislation to comply with international obligations, the Constitutional Court considered that the exclusion from the assistance scheme of non EU disabled juveniles and their families to be in breach of the right to non-discrimination as guaranteed under article 14 of the ECHR and of article 3 of the Constitution providing for equality of treatment [Considerato in diritto, para. 5]. The Court also found violations of article 32 of the Constitution, protecting the right to health; article 34, protecting the right to education; and article 38, protecting the right to social assistance [Considerato in diritto, para. 1].
Additional Comments: The Court makes an implicit distinction between documented and undocumented migrants. This decision is thus limited to the discrimination between citizens and documented migrants based on the long-term nature of the permit. The Court alludes to the possibility of a different outcome in respect of undocumented migrants, considering the existing ECtHR jurisprudence.