The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ), in collaboration with aditus, Human Rights in Practice, Forum for Human Rights, Free Courts organized a workshop for lawyers on judicial independence and strategic litigation in Malta on 23 and 24 November 2023. The event focused on critical issues of judicial independence, including, appointment procedures, administration of justice, and freedom of expression and association of judges.
Judicial independence is essential for democracy and human rights protection, yet it is frequently under attack or pressure. Judicial independence is possible only with independent organisation and governance, and when judges’ human rights are guaranteed. This includes strict selection criteria and transparency in the appointment of judges and prosecutors, and it implies respect of freedom of expression and association of judges.
The participants discussed the challenges in guaranteeing both institutional and individual independence of judges, and in ensuring fairness and transparency in the appointment procedures. The workshop also focused on the possible limitations of the freedom of expression and association of judges. It was noted that judges often fear repercussions for expressing their opinions and participating in associations or protests.
The workshop brought together experts and practitioners from six EU Member States – the Czech Republic, Hungary, Malta, Poland, Romania and Slovakia – to discuss their experiences. The participants discussed the international legal framework and the possible ways to protect judicial independence focusing on the role of strategic litigation.
The event was the second of a series of workshops, each considering different aspects of judicial independence. These workshops aim to contribute to the development of the Final Mapping Report with recommendations on strategic litigation for practitioners in the EU, as part of the ROLL (Rule of Law for Lawyers) project.
Please see the workshop agenda here.
Please find recordings of some of the workshop presentations here.