Thailand: Law on the development of the Eastern Economic Corridor should be revised with a view to addressing concerns of affected persons
“The law governing the development of Thailand’s Eastern Economic Corridor (EEC) must be evaluated and revised to address concerns raised by local communities, and align with Thailand’s international human rights obligations,” concluded participants at a dialogue hosted by the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ), Land Watch Thai, EEC Watch, ENLAW Thai Foundation, and Thai Public Broadcasting Service (Thai PBS) in Bangkok, on 22 November 2023.
Participants shared recommendations aimed at improving the Eastern Special Development Zone Act B.E. 2561 (2018) (‘EEC Act’), which governs the operation of the EEC, to better serve the rights and interests of persons in affected communities. These suggestions will be compiled by the organizers and submitted as part of the official consultation process during the 2024 evaluation by the Office of the Eastern Special Development Zone Policy Committee (‘EEC Office’).
The EEC is a special economic zone in Thailand being developed in the eastern coastal provinces of Rayong, Chonburi, and Chachoengsao, along the Gulf of Thailand. Its objective is to promote investment in next-generation industries utilizing innovation and high technology.
“The EEC Act, however lofty are its stated aim, fails to incorporate adequate protection of human rights. While the EEC Act nominally acknowledges international human rights standards such as the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights’ protect, respect, and remedy framework, as well as the principle of promoting and protecting human rights in policy preparation, it fails to provide for adequate means to ensure implementation of these and other human rights standards,” said Sanhawan Srisod, ICJ’s Legal Adviser.
“According to Thai law, the evaluation must achieve goals that include aligning the law with Thailand’s international obligations under international law. Therefore, the EEC Office cannot complete the evaluation process without thoroughly addressing current gaps in compliance,” added Srisod.
The ICJ recommendations presented include the need to incorporate safeguards against forced eviction, in accordance with international human rights law, and to recognize the social, cultural, spiritual, economic, environmental, and political value of land for communities, with special emphasis on the significance for tenant farmers and small-scale food producers. Responsible land-based investments and implementing human rights due diligence are also critical elements.
A survey conducted before the dialogue with 44 affected individuals in Chonburi and Rayong provinces revealed a pattern of practices that fail to comply with Thailand’s international human rights obligations. They include:
- Lack of adequate participation of residents in the consultation process of the EEC Act.
- Absence of representation of locally affected individuals/communities in the Committee overseeing the EEC, primarily composed of governmental authorities and representatives from business sectors.
- The EEC Committee and Office hold overly broad powers without adequate checks and balances.
- The absence of effective grievance and compliance mechanisms within the EEC Office.
- Disregard for the impact of activities on local livelihoods during policy implementation.
- Ineffectiveness and inadequacy of remedies provided for individuals affected by EEC operations.
Participants suggested amending the EEC Act to address these concerns and ensure real participation, inclusiveness, adequate livelihood, a healthy environment, effective remedies, and other human rights of communities in the area.
Additionally, it addressed ongoing litigation initiated by communities challenging town planning within the EEC, specifically challenging the re-designation of agricultural, natural, and environmental reserved zones to industrial zones, which is currently pending before the Central Administrative Court.
Background
The participants comprised 30 affected individuals living in the areas of the EEC and civil society actors. This is the second dialogue following the initial one in June 2023, addressing the same topic.
According to the Act on Legislative Drafting and Evaluation of Law B.E. 2562 (2019), all Thai laws must undergo outcome evaluation at least every five years.
Speakers at the dialogue included:
- Chanchao Chaiyanukit, Former Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Justice
- Pornpana Kuaycharoen, Land Watch Thai
- Sanhawan Srisod, ICJ
- Saowaruj Rattanakhamfu, Thailand Development Research Institute (TDRI)
- Somnuck Jongmeewasin, EEC Watch
- Sondhi Kodchawat, Environmental Researcher
- Sumitchai Hattasan, Center for Protection and Revival of Local Community Rights
- Supaporn Malailoy, ENLAWThai Foundation
- Sutthikiat Kodchaso, ENLAWThai Foundation
Contact
Sanhawan Srisod, ICJ Associate International Legal Adviser, e: [email protected]
Further reading